Comparison of Estrogenic, Spectroscopic, and Toxicological Analyses of Pilot-Scale Water, Wastewaters, and Processed Wastewaters at Select Military Installations

Reuse of water requires the removal of contaminants to ensure human health. We report the relative estrogenic activity (REA) of reuse treatment design scenarios for water, wastewaters, and processed wastewaters before and after pilot-scale treatment systems tested at select military facilities. The comparative relationships between REA, several composite toxicological endpoints, and spectroscopic indicators were evaluated for different reuse treatment trains. Four treatment processes including conventional and advanced treatments reduced the estrogenicity by at least 33%. Biologically based methods reduced estrogenicity to below detection levels. Conventional treatment scenarios led to significantly less reduction of adverse biological endpoints compared to the advanced treatment scenarios. Incorporating the anaerobic membrane bioreactor reduced more endpoints with higher reduction percentages compared to the sequencing batch reactor design. Membrane technology and advanced oxidation generated reductions across all biological endpoints, from 65% (genotoxicity) to 100% (estrogenicity). The design scenarios featuring a low-cutoff mechanical screen filter, intermittent activated carbon biofilter, and membrane filtration achieved the highest percent reduction and produced water with the lowest negative biological endpoints. Spectroscopic indicators demonstrated case-specific relationships with estrogenicity and toxicity. Estrogenicity consistently correlated with cytotoxicity and thiol reactivity, indicating the potential for preliminary estrogenicity screening using thiol reactivity.