TY - JOUR
T1 - Extensive chameleon mortality in mechanized harvest of grapes suggests that wildlife biodiversity in the agricultural matrix may be a double-edged sword
AU - Sagi, Liran
AU - Topper, Akiva
AU - Keynan, Oded
AU - Bouskila, Amos
AU - Kolodny, Oren
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2025
PY - 2026/1/1
Y1 - 2026/1/1
N2 - The global pervasiveness of agriculture and its profound effects on biodiversity increasingly mandate developing sustainable agricultural methods to support healthy ecosystems within agricultural landscapes. However, increasing the attractiveness of agricultural landscapes for wildlife may negatively impact biodiversity if animals or their reproduction are adversely affected in such habitats. While the effects of agricultural practices were investigated across various crop types and wildlife species, reptiles remain largely overlooked. Additionally, although reptiles in croplands were monitored throughout the farming season, little attention has been directed towards the effects of harvest at the season's end. To illustrate the potential impacts of mechanical harvest on wildlife in permanent crops, we present a case-study concerning reptiles in vineyards. We scanned the waste of a medium-sized winery over four nights and found 105 reptiles, 69 % of them chameleons. Though chameleons are considered carnivorous, approximately half had consumed grapes, potentially attracted by them. Vineyards, like many crops, offer resources including sugar, moisture, and shelter, likely attracting many wildlife species. However, mortality during mechanical harvest may be high, potentially rendering such crops an ecological trap. For chameleons the effects may be particularly devastating, as harvest closely precedes the egg-laying season. While our case study focuses on reptiles in vineyards, its implications extend to many species in croplands. Ultimately, ecological traps affect biodiversity by attracting animals to habitats in which their fitness is impaired.
AB - The global pervasiveness of agriculture and its profound effects on biodiversity increasingly mandate developing sustainable agricultural methods to support healthy ecosystems within agricultural landscapes. However, increasing the attractiveness of agricultural landscapes for wildlife may negatively impact biodiversity if animals or their reproduction are adversely affected in such habitats. While the effects of agricultural practices were investigated across various crop types and wildlife species, reptiles remain largely overlooked. Additionally, although reptiles in croplands were monitored throughout the farming season, little attention has been directed towards the effects of harvest at the season's end. To illustrate the potential impacts of mechanical harvest on wildlife in permanent crops, we present a case-study concerning reptiles in vineyards. We scanned the waste of a medium-sized winery over four nights and found 105 reptiles, 69 % of them chameleons. Though chameleons are considered carnivorous, approximately half had consumed grapes, potentially attracted by them. Vineyards, like many crops, offer resources including sugar, moisture, and shelter, likely attracting many wildlife species. However, mortality during mechanical harvest may be high, potentially rendering such crops an ecological trap. For chameleons the effects may be particularly devastating, as harvest closely precedes the egg-laying season. While our case study focuses on reptiles in vineyards, its implications extend to many species in croplands. Ultimately, ecological traps affect biodiversity by attracting animals to habitats in which their fitness is impaired.
KW - Agroecology
KW - Fitness traps
KW - Preference traps
KW - Wine
UR - https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/105026193015
U2 - 10.1016/j.gecco.2025.e04038
DO - 10.1016/j.gecco.2025.e04038
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:105026193015
SN - 2351-9894
VL - 65
JO - Global Ecology and Conservation
JF - Global Ecology and Conservation
M1 - e04038
ER -