List and Certificate Complexities in Replicable Learning

We investigate replicable learning algorithms. Informally a learning algorithm is replicable if the algorithm outputs the same canonical hypothesis over multiple runs with high probability, even when different runs observe a different set of samples from the unknown data distribution. In general, such a strong notion of replicability is not achievable. Thus we consider two feasible notions of replicability called list replicability and certificate replicability. Intuitively, these notions capture the degree of (non) replicability. The goal is to design learning algorithms with optimal list and certificate complexities while minimizing the sample complexity. Our contributions are the following. - We first study the learning task of estimating the biases of d coins, up to an additive error of ε, by observing samples. For this task, we design a (d + 1)-list replicable algorithm. To complement this result, we establish that the list complexity is optimal, i.e there are no learning algorithms with a list size smaller than d + 1 for this task. We also design learning algorithms with certificate complexity Õ(log d). The sample complexity of both these algorithms is Õ(^d_ε2² ) where ε is the approximation error parameter (for a constant error probability). - In the PAC model, we show that any hypothesis class that is learnable with d-nonadaptive statistical queries can be learned via a (d + 1)-list replicable algorithm and also via a Õ(log d)-certificate replicable algorithm. The sample complexity of both these algorithms is Õ(_ν^d2₂ ) where ν is the approximation error of the statistical query. We also show that for the concept class dTHRESHOLD, the list complexity is exactly d + 1 with respect to the uniform distribution. To establish our upper bound results we use rounding schemes induced by geometric partitions with certain properties. We use Sperner/KKM Lemma to establish the lower bound results.