TY - JOUR
T1 - Radium removal in a large scale evaporitic system
AU - Rosenberg, Yoav Oved
AU - Metz, Volker
AU - Ganor, Jiwchar
N1 - Funding Information:
We greatly appreciate the discussion with Carlos M. Pina. The technical help of Yael Leshno, Tali Edery, Yonatan Sadeh, Martina Schlieker and Eva Soballa is highly appreciated. We also wish to express our gratitude to Sharon Zmora-Nahum from Mekorot, the Israel National Water Company, and to the operators of the Ketziot desalination plant, Ofir Shmoely and Roy Ben Shoshan. This study was supported by THE ISRAEL SCIENCE FOUNDATION (Grant #511/09 ). Y.O. Rosenberg is supported by the Adams Fellowship Program of the Israel Academy of Sciences and Humanities and is also grateful to the Rieger Foundation’s JNF Program for Environmental Studies and the Water Authority of Israel for their generous support.
PY - 2013/2/5
Y1 - 2013/2/5
N2 - The removal of radium during co-precipitation with barite (BaSO4) (i.e., the precipitation of a (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution) is an important process with many geochemical applications. During the last century the precipitation of (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution was extensively studied in laboratory experiments at different temperature and salinities. The outcome of such small scale experiments often serves in theoretical safety assessments simulation, but was hardly tested over large scale field systems.In this study the precipitation of Ra was investigated in a large scale field system and found to be controlled by the formation of a (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution. The results are comparable to laboratory based studies conducted with the same solution. The field system is comprised of six sequential evaporation ponds and has a total volume of ∼3.25×105m3. In the ponds a reject brine of a desalination plant is evaporated. The non-evaporated brine has an ionic strength of 0.7m, 226Ra concentration of ∼12Bqkg-1, and it is oversaturated with respect to gypsum, celestite and barite. Upon its evaporation the ionic strength increases up to 12m, and a total amount of ∼4×106kgyear-1 of sulphate minerals precipitates.Chemical analysis of solid samples collected from the ponds revealed that the precipitation of Ra is concurrent with Ba, indicating on the formation of a (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution. A detailed mass balance of the different solutes in the brine of the ponds allowed us to quantitatively study the effects of ionic strength and precipitation kinetics on the (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution composition. The results of the present field study were comparable to laboratory based experiments, suggesting that in the complex field system, as in the lab, the same factors affect the formation of the (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution.It is shown that as a result of both ionic strength and kinetic effects the solid solution composition is less Ra enriched; i.e., the concentration-based partition coefficient, K'D,barite, decreased from its so-called thermodynamic value (1.8) to ∼1. Consequently, the removal of Ra through the precipitation of the (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution is attenuated and Ra concentration in the aqueous solutions can be as much as 300% higher than anticipated if K'D,barite would have been equal to 1.8. By calculating the activity-based partition coefficient, K″D,barite, both effects could be separated and studied quantitatively. It is shown that an increase of ∼1 order of magnitude in barite precipitation rate leads to a decrease in the value of K″D,barite from ∼1.8 to ∼1.
AB - The removal of radium during co-precipitation with barite (BaSO4) (i.e., the precipitation of a (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution) is an important process with many geochemical applications. During the last century the precipitation of (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution was extensively studied in laboratory experiments at different temperature and salinities. The outcome of such small scale experiments often serves in theoretical safety assessments simulation, but was hardly tested over large scale field systems.In this study the precipitation of Ra was investigated in a large scale field system and found to be controlled by the formation of a (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution. The results are comparable to laboratory based studies conducted with the same solution. The field system is comprised of six sequential evaporation ponds and has a total volume of ∼3.25×105m3. In the ponds a reject brine of a desalination plant is evaporated. The non-evaporated brine has an ionic strength of 0.7m, 226Ra concentration of ∼12Bqkg-1, and it is oversaturated with respect to gypsum, celestite and barite. Upon its evaporation the ionic strength increases up to 12m, and a total amount of ∼4×106kgyear-1 of sulphate minerals precipitates.Chemical analysis of solid samples collected from the ponds revealed that the precipitation of Ra is concurrent with Ba, indicating on the formation of a (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution. A detailed mass balance of the different solutes in the brine of the ponds allowed us to quantitatively study the effects of ionic strength and precipitation kinetics on the (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution composition. The results of the present field study were comparable to laboratory based experiments, suggesting that in the complex field system, as in the lab, the same factors affect the formation of the (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution.It is shown that as a result of both ionic strength and kinetic effects the solid solution composition is less Ra enriched; i.e., the concentration-based partition coefficient, K'D,barite, decreased from its so-called thermodynamic value (1.8) to ∼1. Consequently, the removal of Ra through the precipitation of the (Ra,Ba)SO4 solid solution is attenuated and Ra concentration in the aqueous solutions can be as much as 300% higher than anticipated if K'D,barite would have been equal to 1.8. By calculating the activity-based partition coefficient, K″D,barite, both effects could be separated and studied quantitatively. It is shown that an increase of ∼1 order of magnitude in barite precipitation rate leads to a decrease in the value of K″D,barite from ∼1.8 to ∼1.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84871378500&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.gca.2012.10.046
DO - 10.1016/j.gca.2012.10.046
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:84871378500
SN - 0016-7037
VL - 103
SP - 121
EP - 137
JO - Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
JF - Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
ER -